Order Pies online to pickup!
(Orders must be placed at least 48 hours in advance.)
Rusty's Turtle
Frozen custard, caramel, hot fudge, roasted pecans, whipped cream and a cherry.
Fudgin' Delicous
Frozen custard, hot fudge, roasted pecans, whipped cream and a cherry.
Gameday
Vanilla custard with bananas and strawberries
The Foreman
Vanilla custard with Reeses Cups®, Butterfinger® and peanut butter
The New Yorker
Vanilla custard with creme de menthe and chocolate chips
Flying Elvis
Vanilla custard with bananas and peanut butter
Butter Pecan
Vanilla custard with pecans and butterscotch
Razzmatazz
Chocolate custard with Oreos® and raspberries
Love Machine
Vanilla custard with strawberries and chocolate flakes
Cherry Bomb
Vanilla custard with Cherries and Heath Bar®
Union Boss
Chocolate custard with Reeses Cups®, peanut butter and tipped with hot fudge
Dirty Harry
Vanilla custard with bananas and fudge brownie
Blue Suede Shoes
Vanilla custard with Twix® and blueberries
Beach Bum
Vanilla custard with pineapple and coconut
Disco Nap
Vanilla custard with coffee and chocolate flakes
Sticky Snicky
Vanilla custard Snickers® and salted caramel
Order up to 10 pumpkin pies
or 3 custom pies per order.
Want to order more?
Call us at 405-310-5050.